9 of the Best NYC Therapists Who Accept Aetna
Flexible scheduling with 7-day-per-week daytime and evening availability
Intersectional, feminist approach that honors all identities and backgrounds
Careful therapist matching because we prioritize the right fit above everything else
Diverse, culturally competent therapists who understand your unique lived experience
Evidence-based approaches combining psychodynamic and CBT techniques for measurable results
Insurance-friendly practice that accepts Aetna and offers a boutique experience
About New York City Psychotherapy Collective
New York City Psychotherapy Collective is a diverse group practice founded on the belief that everyone deserves a therapist who truly understands their experience.
That's why our clinicians come from various ethnic, religious, and generational backgrounds, speaking multiple languages and bringing culturally competent, anti-racist perspectives to every session.
We also believe you shouldn't have to choose between quality and accessibility, which is why we’re proud to be in-network with multiple insurance plans, including all New York State Aetna plans and the Aetna EAP plan.
9 NYC Aetna therapists ready for hire
Anxiety therapists who accept Aetna
Greta Weiss
☑️ Accepts Aetna
🛋️Specialties: Highly sensitive people, anxiety, life transitions, breakups
⭐️ Uses modern frameworks like Enneagrams, Myers-Briggs, and even Tarot to help clients connect with themselves
Julia LaPlaza
☑️ Accepts Aetna
🛋️Specialties: Anxiety, depression, relationship difficulties, college and young adult issues
⭐️ Bilingual therapist who understands the unique pressure of trying to please everyone while navigating cultural expectations
Allie Soss
☑️ Accepts Aetna
🛋️Specialties: Anxiety, overthinking, negative self-talk, relationship stress, imposter syndrome
⭐️ Combines Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) and Person-Centered therapy to create a collaborative environment where you can start understanding yourself better
Depression therapists who accept Aetna
Remi Reich
☑️ Accepts Aetna
🛋️Specialties: Depression, anxiety, self-esteem, life transitions, recent graduates
⭐️ Helps college-aged women and recent grads build resilience and practical skills for navigating the "quarter-life crisis" years
Liz Bruno
☑️ Accepts Aetna
🛋️Specialties: Depression, anxiety, life transitions, adolescents and adults
⭐️ Believes therapy is first and foremost about authentic human connection, has a warm and collaborative approach
Trauma therapists who accept Aetna
Laina Mason
☑️ Accepts Aetna
🛋️Specialties: Trauma, sexual trauma, perinatal issues, LGBTQIA+ affirmative therapy
⭐️ Background competing at high levels in Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu, bringing unique insight into managing high-pressure situations and stress
Johanna Bellorin
☑️ Accepts Aetna
🛋️Specialties: Immigration and cultural trauma, life transitions, grief, relationship challenges
⭐️ Offers therapy in both Spanish and English, bringing humor and sarcasm when it fits to keep clients grounded
Couples therapists who accept Aetna
Lily Ostler
☑️ Accepts Aetna
🛋️Specialties: Sex therapy, couples therapy, relationship milestones, intimacy concerns, non-monogamy
⭐️ Certified sex therapist and queer woman who welcomes all relationship structures and uses humor to create comfortable conversations about difficult topics
Maggie McCarthy
☑️ Accepts Aetna
🛋️Specialties: Women and LGBTQIA+ individuals/couples, relationship patterns, communication, loneliness
⭐️ Makes space for humor and levity in sessions because she believes laughter is essential for healing
FAQs about therapy
-
We are in-network providers with all New York state Aetna plans and the Aetna EAP plan, making therapy accessible and affordable for our clients. Our team is also approved as out-of-network providers for other commercial healthcare plans. Read more about using insurance to pay for therapy here.
-
Most Aetna plans include mental health coverage, but benefits vary by plan. We recommend calling the member services number on your insurance card or checking your plan documents online. Our team can also verify your coverage and explain your copay, deductible, and session limits if you need help.
-
If you're feeling stuck, overwhelmed, anxious, or like you're just going through the motions, therapy can help. Many of our clients come to us when their usual coping strategies aren't working anymore, or when they want to understand patterns in their relationships, work, or emotions. You don't need to be in crisis to benefit from therapy.
-
We specialize in anxiety, depression, life transitions, relationship challenges, work stress, trauma, and identity exploration. Our therapists also have expertise in areas like substance use, eating disorders, perinatal mental health, and couples therapy. We focus on helping high-achieving individuals who feel burned out, overwhelmed, or disconnected from themselves.
-
Therapy provides insight into your patterns, practical tools for managing difficult emotions, and a safe space to process your experiences. Our clients often report feeling more confident, having better relationships, improved communication skills, and a clearer sense of their values and boundaries. We focus on helping people create measurable, lasting change.
-
All our clinicians use evidence-based approaches, primarily combining psychodynamic therapy and cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT). We tailor our methods to each client's specific needs, goals, and preferences. And no matter which specific methods our therapists use, our practice is grounded in feminist, intersectional, and anti-racist principles, ensuring culturally responsive care for all clients.
-
Therapy typically begins with understanding your concerns and goals, then exploring patterns and developing new skills. Sessions are collaborative conversations where you'll gain insights, practice new tools, and work toward sustainable change. Progress isn't always linear, but most clients notice improvements in how they feel and function within a few sessions.
-
We prioritize the perfect therapist-client match above everything else. During your free consultation, you'll speak with our team about your needs and preferences. We'll match you with a therapist who understands your background, identity, and goals. If the first match isn't perfect, we'll help you find the right fit within our practice.
-
Simply book a free consultation call where we'll discuss your needs, answer questions about insurance and our approach, and match you with the right therapist for you. From there, we'll schedule your first session and handle all the insurance paperwork.